Round 1 of the Solar Energy Innovation Network
The first round of the Solar Energy Innovation Network comprises nine teams that are developing new ways for solar energy to improve the affordability, reliability, and resiliency of the electric grid.
Teams in the first round of the Solar Energy Innovation Network are:
- Developing methods and tools to identify solar potential on a city-wide scale to inform planning
- Producing a distribution system modeling tool to support distribution utility decisions by identifying the benefits and impacts of adding distributed energy resources (DERs) to specific locations on the grid
- Modeling the economics of novel applications of photovoltaics (PV), such as pairing it with electric vehicle (EV) charging at workplaces or with storage for peak demand reduction
- Working with stakeholders to prioritize energy goals and design pilot projects that demonstrate novel, cost-effective solar and DER solutions
- Assessing the resiliency value of DERs and other value streams.
In addition to team-level efforts, the Innovation Network is producing products and tools to address questions identified by multiple teams, including:
- Understanding the potential impact of EVs on electricity demand
- Identifying considerations for the structure of new solar tariffs and programs
- Developing local plans for moving from solar energy goals to implementation
- Analyzing and compensating locational value of solar to provide grid and resiliency benefits.
The nine teams participating in the first round of the Solar Energy Innovation Network were grouped into two cohorts, based on shared challenges and goals. The stakeholder teams participating in the Innovation Network are making rapid progress toward new, multi-technology solutions such as the pairing of PV and EVs, as well as provision of grid services with PV and storage. Their ongoing projects are described below.
Improving Reliability and Affordability of Renewable Energy through Options Analysis and Systems Design Cohort
This cohort, also called the "Options Analysis" cohort, focuses on identifying the grid impacts and costs anticipated for various penetration levels of solar and other DERs. This includes:
- Developing data sets and geospatial mapping tools that assess impacts on reliability of various levels of variable generation at municipal or utility service territory scale
- Identifying and validate new solar siting methods that minimize grid impacts and reduce distribution system costs
- Identifying innovative ownership models, financing structures, and procurement strategies
- Exploring options for the integrated planning and deployment of solar and electric vehicles and solar+storage
- Exploring alternative rate designs and compensation mechanisms.
The five project teams for this cohort are described below.
Lead Organization: City of Orlando
Team Members: City of Orlando, Orlando Utility Commission, UCF Florida Solar Energy Center, Greenlink
Project Description: The City of Orlando aims to deploy solar and solar-plus-storage to support energy resiliency, environmental quality, and the continued affordability of the electricity supply. The team’s efforts include identifying the total solar potential available city-wide and conducting more detailed analysis for municipal facilities and distribution grid modeling. A pilot project to demonstrate innovative siting solutions is also being planned. The team is producing insights on municipal-level solar policies and building guidelines to share with other municipalities.
States Represented: Florida
Lead Organization: City of San Diego
Team Members: City of San Diego, Clean Coalition, San Diego Gas & Electric (invited partner)
Project Description: The City of San Diego aims to deploy solar and storage to support energy resiliency, environmental quality, and affordability of the electricity supply. The team has estimated the total potential for solar deployment across the city, designed a program proposal for utilizing the total solar potential, completed detailed economic analysis of solar options on municipal facilities, conducted stakeholder workshops to explore solar compensation options, and is exploring opportunities for solar-plus-storage to improve resiliency at critical facilities.
States Represented: California
Lead Organization: Montana Renewable Energy Association
Team Members: Montana Renewable Energy Association, Montana Energy Office at the Department of Environmental Quality, City of Missoula, City of Bozeman, City of Whitefish, Climate Smart Missoula, Yellowstone-Teton Clean Cities
Project Description: The Montana team is investigating the synergies between solar generation and EV charging, including the potential opportunities and challenges related to co-locating solar energy and charging infrastructure to reduce costs and enhance co-benefits of the electrification of transportation. All of the cities participating in the program (Bozeman, Missoula, and Whitefish) have held stakeholder engagement meetings to clarify goals and strengthened their relationship with the utility through continued dialogue. The City of Missoula’s transit agency has purchased six electric buses and conducted analysis to understand specific options for locating charging infrastructure with solar generation. The team is writing a report to share the broader lessons learned with other communities across Montana and the United States.
States Represented: Montana
Lead Organization: Utah Clean Energy
Team Members: Utah Clean Energy, City of Moab, Park City, Salt Lake City, Rocky Mountain Power
Project Description: The Utah team is conducting scenario analysis to evaluate the potential to employ demand-side measures, such as energy efficiency, solar, and storage to support city-level energy goals and complement utility-scale solar being planned by their utility. The team is also estimating the potential additional future load that may be associated with beneficial residential electrification and electric vehicle adoption in the cities. These analyses inform a regional energy planning process and city input to the utility integrated resource planning process.
States represented: Utah
Lead organization: Kit Carson Electric Cooperative (KCEC)
Team Members: KCEC, Guzman Energy, Renewable Taos
Project Description: KCEC is currently partnering with multiple stakeholders to plan the deployment of an additional 35 megawatts of solar photovoltaics by strategically deploying smaller one-megawatt solar arrays across their service area. In coordination with NREL, the team has developed a tool to identify the benefits and impacts of solar-plus-storage at specific locations on the grid, conduct complex scenario analyses across an entire distribution system, and identify opportunities for infrastructure and operational cost savings and improved resilience. Using the model, the team is writing an operational plan for solar build-out on their system. The model will be made available to other cooperative utilities interested in deploying solar. The team will share lessons learned, including insights on the shifts needed in organizational structure, systems, and procedures that will help build the internal capacity necessary for cooperative utilities to apply the tool.
States Represented: New Mexico
Improving Grid Flexibility and Resiliency through Advanced Siting and Operations of Solar + DER Cohort
This cohort, also called the "Grid Flex" cohort, focuses on quantifying the value of combining solar and other DERs, such as storage, for grid flexibility, reliability, and resiliency. Activities for this cohort include (but aren't limited to):
- Assessing opportunities to improve PV's value through siting, load management, storage, and better integration with transportation electrification
- Evaluating options for rate structures and other compensation mechanisms to effectively
value solar + DER systems' various value streams
- Exploring program and policy options to maximize the value of solar + DER, incl. locational value and wholesale market participation
- Improving utility and ISO/RTO planning to incorporate PV and other DERs, and enhance grid resiliency and flexibility
- Developing needed data sets and tools for states and ISOs to evaluate solar + DER solutions for increased grid resiliency.
The four project teams participating in this cohort are described below:
Lead Organizations: PJM Interconnection and National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC)
Team Members: NARUC, PJM Interconnection, Converge Strategies LLC
Project Description: This project is studying opportunities for solar to provide system resilience both at distribution and bulk power levels. The team members are identifying market barriers and potential pathways forward with input from key stakeholders including member utilities, relevant federal, state, and local governments, regulators, developers, solution providers, and the United States military.
The team began by conducting a detailed review of resilience valuation methodologies being tested across the country. This will be paired with a review of regulatory approaches to encouraging DERs and opportunities for DERs to provide resiliency benefits. The team has convened three stakeholder workshops to gather diverse perspectives and map out pathways to realizing resiliency benefits from DERs. The team is also exploring a concrete case study of solar for resilience by analyzing and modeling the potential for solar-plus-storage to provide black start services for PJM. This includes assessing technical feasibility, operational challenges, and business model barriers. This research is supporting modeling feasibility for specific systems to pilot black start applications of solar and storage. The team is also producing a market and regulatory roadmap for effectively integrating resilient DERs.
States Represented: PJM territory (includes Delaware, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia, and the District of Columbia), and NARUC member commissions.
Lead Organization: Clean Energy States Alliance
Team Members: Clean Energy States Alliance, Connecticut (Connecticut Green Bank), District of Columbia (Office of the People’s Counsel for the District of Columbia), New Hampshire (New Hampshire Public Utilities Commission), Rhode Island (Rhode Island Office of Energy Resources), Washington (Washington Department of Commerce’s State Energy Office), Wisconsin (Wisconsin Office of Energy Innovation)
Project Description: This project is exploring approaches for identifying high-value locations for distributed solar and other DERs to reduce grid congestion, to avoid or defer distribution system upgrades, and to provide resiliency benefits. The team is composed of five states and the District of Columbia that are all looking at specific elements of analyzing and compensating locational value. This includes studies to evaluate compensation mechanisms, data needs to advance locational siting, potential roles of locational value in the integrated resource planning process, the economics of utilizing solar-plus-storage to manage peak demand growth, and siting for resilience benefits. Advancements and lessons learned from this project will be shared to assist other states facing similar opportunities and challenges.
States Represented: Connecticut, District of Columbia, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Washington, and Wisconsin
Publications: State Strategies for Valuing Distributed Energy Resources in Cost-Effective Locations, Clean Energy States Alliance (2020)
Lead Organization: Great Plains Institute
Team Members: Great Plains Institute, Minnesota Department of Commerce, Minnesota Department of Administration, ZEF Energy, Metropolitan Council, Minnesota Solar Energy Industries Association, Center for Energy and Environment
Project Description: This project is examining synergies between EV charging infrastructure and distributed solar energy. The project is assessing technical applications, potential partnerships, and opportunities for local and state policies to create mutually beneficial co-deployment of solar and EVs in Minnesota. The Minnesota team used both stakeholder engagement and economic analysis to examine market potential and barriers to deployment. The team convened a broad suite of stakeholders in a series of workshops, interviews, and surveys to assess value propositions, foster partnerships, and evaluate potential solar plus EV charging use cases. Technoeconomic analysis of priority use cases, such as workplace charging, municipal fleet charging, or public transit electrification, complemented the stakeholder input. Pilot projects are being pursued to stress test EV and solar synergies and ultimately inform the development of a roadmap for cost-effective solar and EV co-deployment while supporting grid reliability. The roadmap will be a valuable tool for other states and cities that are preparing for growth in EVs and solar, particularly in contexts with low penetrations of either or both.
States Represented: Minnesota
Lead Organization: Center for Climate Protection
Team Members: Center for Climate Protection, TerraVerde Energy LLC, Lancaster Choice Energy, Peninsula Clean Energy
Project Description: This project is developing tools and methodologies for evaluate the opportunities and trade-ofs across various rate structures for integrated DER deployment. Design decisions were based on a multi-month stakeholder input process that included a number of community choice aggregations, solutions providers, and regulatory policy and rate design experts, among others. The rate design tool will be technology-agnostic (e.g., distributed solar PV, energy efficiency, energy storage, electric vehicles, and demand response technologies) and load-serving entities (LSEs) can readily adopt and customize to support their community goals while maintaining affordability.
The tool will provide a transparent methodology for valuing the costs and benefits of DER installations that can also be adapted and customized to conditions in LSE territories. The tool is being piloted virtually with community choice aggregations partner to evaluate impacts of proposed rate designs on prospective solar and storage projects, but the methodologies applied to DER cost and benefit analysis and the rate structure concepts the tool analyzes will support any LSE.
States Represented: California
SEIN teams, NREL, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, and other supporting organizations have produced various publications to document their work as part of the Innovation Network. They are made available here to help other communities and organizations understand and replicate the solutions developed by the Innovation Network.
Solar Energy Innovation Network Teams
These publications were produced by SEIN teams, which are comprised of a variety of organizations. These publications do not necessarily represent the work or views of NREL.
The Value of Resilience for Distributed Energy Resources: An Overview of Current Analytical Practices, Converge Strategies, LLC (2019)
Advancing Electric System Resilience with Distributed Energy Resources: A Review of State Policies, National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (2020)
Advancing Electric System Resilience with Distributed Energy Resources: Key Questions and Resources, National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (2020)
State Strategies for Valuing Distributed Energy Resources in Cost-Effective Locations, Clean Energy States Alliance (2020)
Solar Power + Electric Vehicle Charging: Capturing Synergies in Minnesota, Great Plains Institute (2020)
Navigating Options for Transportation Electrification and Solar Charging, Montana Team (2020)
NREL and Other Organizations
These publications were produced by national laboratories or other supporting organizations to inform SEIN team projects. These publications do not necessarily represent the work or views of NREL.
Distributed Rate Design: A Review of Early Approaches and Practical Considerations for Value of Solar Tariffs, The Electricity Journal (2019)
Current Developments in Retail Rate Design: Implications for Solar and Other Distributed Energy Resources, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (2019)
Capturing More Value from Combinations of PV and Other Distributed Energy Resources, Regulatory Assistance Project (2019)
Blackstart of Power Grids with Inverter-Based Resources, NREL Conference Paper (2020)
Economics of Solar with Storage for Municipal Sites in the City of San Diego, NREL Presentation (2019)
Evaluating Utility Costs Savings for EV Charging Infrastructure, NREL Presentation (2019)
NREL Presentation (2019)
The Peer Network branch of the Innovation Network is designed to enhance the replicability of innovative solutions through tailored analytical support and peer exchange. Leveraging experience and lessons learned across the cohorts, Peer Network teams receive assistance in adapting research, analytical pathways, and innovative approaches to their individual contexts.
Six Peer Network teams were selected to receive targeted assistance in the first round of the Innovation Network.
Lead Organization: University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa
Stakeholders: REDLab, State of Hawaii Division of Consumer Advocacy
Relevant Efforts: The long-term objective of this team is to develop coordinated control algorithms for battery energy storage systems (BESS) to mitigate hosting capacity constraints on distribution circuits for solar PV systems. In the near-term, University of Hawaiʻi at Mãnoa researchers are developing a BESS performance model using real-world and test bed data. Using this BESS performance model, the team is developing an economic model to estimate the economic impact to customers purchasing PV generation and/or BESS across a spectrum of policy, program, and rate structure scenarios. The State of Hawaii Division of Consumer Advocacy's role in the team is limited to providing guidance on key policy issues and does not involve the provision of data resources.
Geographic Area Represented: Hawai'i
Lead Organization: New York Power Authority (NYPA)
Relevant Efforts: NYPA is a state-owned generation and transmission provider charged with the provision of reliable, low-cost, and clean electricity and energy services for the benefit of high-load-factor industrial, commercial, governmental, and municipal customers. NYPA's Energy Diversity through Grid Edge (EDGE) initiative is focused on finding new and innovative ways to deliver distributed energy resources to customers. Interventions currently range from simple energy efficiency measures, such as LED lighting installation, to development and operation of combined solar and energy storage assets. In the short term, the team is focusing on solar and storage for its 51 municipal and cooperative customers. Moving forward, NYPA will look to test more advanced value-based services and products such as load aggregation, load management, and peer-to-peer trading.
Geographic Area Represented: New York
Lead Organization: Clean Energy Economy for the Region (CLEER)
Stakeholders: Garfield Clean Energy (government collaborative), Eagle County, Pitkin County, Xcel Energy, Holy Cross Energy, Glenwood Springs Municipal Utility, Aspen Municipal Utility, CLEER, Community Office for Resource Efficiency (CORE)
Relevant Efforts: The Western Colorado Rural Clean Energy Corridor initiative is a collaborative team spanning three counties in western Colorado. The team aims to create and implement a shared roadmap to meet the region's renewable energy goals while maximizing resilience and local economic diversification. The effort will focus on developing a regional approach to renewable energy development that meets a diverse set of economic drivers and objectives.
Geographic Areas Represented: Colorado; Garfield, Pitkin, and Eagle Counties; Communities of Parachute, Rifle, Silt, New Castle, Glenwood Springs, Carbondale, Basalt, Aspen, Snowmass Village, Eagle, Vail, Avon, Gypsum, Minturn
Lead Organization: Redwood Coast Energy Authority (RCEA)
Stakeholders: RCEA, Humboldt County Planning and Building Permitting Department, Schatz Energy Research Center, The Energy Authority
Relevant Efforts: RCEA is a community choice aggregator in Humboldt County, California that has been procuring electric power on behalf of some 60,000 customers in the county since May 2017. The RCEA team is in the process of developing a 2.1 megawatt solar PV / 2 megawatt (8 megawatt-hour) battery storage microgrid system at the local airport. In addition to technical considerations, the RCEA team is also exploring a range of market and transactional questions related to microgrid development, including how costs and benefits will be allocated across customers, potential resilience value streams, and which energy markets to participate in.
Geographic Area Represented: Humboldt County, California
Lead Organization: Extensible Energy
Stakeholders: Extensible Energy
Relevant Efforts: Extensible Energy is exploring new business models and partner ecosystems to simplify combined solar, storage, and load management solutions for commercial energy customers. These efforts compliment the team's ongoing software development and testing initiatives to enable commercial customers to maximize the use of behind-the-meter solar PV installations through a combination of energy storage and automated load flexibility solutions.
Geographic Areas Represented: California
Lead Organization: Seven Generations Ahead
Stakeholders: Village of Oak Park; Village of River Forest; Oak Park River Forest Community Foundation; Oak Park Residence Corporation; Oak Park Housing Authority; Park District of Oak Park; Seven Generations Ahead; Illinois Community Choice Aggregation Network
Relevant Efforts: The Oak Park-River Forest PlanItGreen initiative incorporates a combination of renewable energy road map planning and implementation, with an emphasis on low-to-moderate income (LMI) and non-profit procurement goals. Strategies and objectives include: (1) creating a solar energy development and procurement road map for the villages of Oak Park and River Forest, Illinois; (2) developing and implementing a pipeline of solar projects, including behind-the-meter on-site installations, community solar, and utility-scale project that collectively meet renewable energy, LMI, and non-profit procurement goals; (3) identifying and overcoming barriers to grid connections, LMI household enrollment, and non-profit power purchase agreement contracts; (4) developing outreach, education and enrollment strategies that connect LMI households and multi-family building complexes with solar applications; and (5) adapting successful strategies and lessons-learned across Chicago metro area communities.
Geographic Areas Represented: Oak Park and River Forest, Illinois